Exploring new technologies in Japan’s liberalized market

Makoto Watanabe, executive director of NEDO in Japan, talks about the country’s changing energy market.
Published: Fri 09 Sep 2016

Watanabe, who is also the secretary general of Japan Smart Community Alliance (JSCA), vice chair of the Global Smart Grid Federation (GSGF) and current chair of GSGF’s energy storage work group, spoke about the role of new energy technologies such as battery storage in Japan’s democratised electricity market.

A semi-governmental organisation established in 1980, the New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organisation (NEDO) was created for the development and introduction of new energy technologies, following the two oil crises in Japan in the 1970s. Earlier this year, the Power Grid Electrical Storage working group of the GSGF, of which Makoto Watanabe is chair, published a report on electrical storage which determined the possibilities of battery storage in the electrical grid as viable on a global scale.

When asked how he expects the role of new energy technologies, such as battery storage, to evolve in Japan’s liberalising market, Watanabe says that battery technology is still a nascent technology in the Japanese energy market, but anticipates that this will change as renewables regain strength in the market. He regards battery storage as a viable option to compensate for load fluctuations for renewable integration and a key facilitator in load levelling and reliability/ quality improvement.

He adds that supportive government policy, such as subsidy payouts for battery storage through the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) and its FIT programme, offers very generous feed-in tariffs (FIT) for renewable energy generation and will serve to accelerate adoption.

Last year, the Japanese government announced the new FIT rate for the fiscal year 2015. The new FIT rate for residential solar photovoltaic (PV) systems was set at ¥33/kWh (US$0.30), down from ¥37/kWh (US$0.33) the previous fiscal year.

According to Bloomberg New Energy Finance’s (BNEF) Q1 2016 PV Solar Market Outlook, Japan’s annual PV solar installation is expected to reach between 13.2GW and 14.3GW in 2016.

The report explains that grid constraints will curb future installations. Challenges of land acquisition and securing financing for projects will also curtail demand for solar PV in 2017 and beyond, said BNEF.

Accompanying Watanabe in the interview was Yuichiro Shimura, a member of the energy storage work group from JSCA and a consultant for the Mitsubishi research Institute. He adds that the cost of battery storage in Japan is still too high to warrant a leap in technology adoption by homeowners and commercial business.

Shimura said that the average cost for a residential battery storage unit is ¥1,000,000 (US$9,015) – equivalent to ¥1000 (US$9.01) to ¥2000 (US$18.03) per kWh.

He adds: “Batteries are not the only means by which utilities can integrate new sources of energy – tap changers and SVC (static var compensators) are the popular alternatives for distribution voltage control. However, should the cost of battery systems decrease, they will become a lot more prevalent.”

Apart from battery storage, the METI has also rolled out a US$779 million scheme incentivising the use of energy efficient technologies such as lighting, efficient boiler technology and distributed energy storage, targeting factories and small businesses.

Building an energy efficiency culture

Use of energy efficiency technologies is conservative amongst households and businesses, said Watanabe. He goes on to say that the use of home energy management systems (HEMS), building energy management systems (BEMS) and energy management systems in manufacturing are slowly gaining traction. However, he points out that currently only 0.2% of homes in Japan utilise HEMS technology.

Telecommunications providers are also expected to influence the technology and services consumers use in their homes and businesses. Electric state-utility TEPCO has partnered with telecommunications provider SoftBank, allowing TEPCO to extend its service area beyond Tokyo and bundle its services now that the full liberalisation of the retail electricity sales market has occurred. Shimura says that historically Japanese utilities have invested in information and communication infrastructure like fibre optics, which has laid the foundation for next generation networks such as 4G and 5G. Utilities traditionally built and operated these networks, said Shimura, but approximately 5-10 years ago, telecommunications companies began to take ownership of these networks and are now beginning to expand into the electricity market.

Telecommunications companies such SoftBank and gas providers in Japan are set to take advantage of the market liberalisation. With over 250 new entrants into the market listed for registration on 1 April, former electricity monopolies will need to innovate to retain their customer base.

According to Watanabe, the less familiar concept of switching is evident in the 1% switching rate amongst residential consumers.

He concludes by saying: “Only time will tell whether customers will embrace the practice of switching and leverage the deregulated market to benefit from competitive prices and services.”

This interview appeared in Metering & Smart Energy International Issue 2 2016.

Related Webinar